Tr
Can A Class Action Be Decertified After It Has Been Approved
Categories
General

Can a Class Action Be Decertified After It Has Been Approved?

Receiving class certification is an important step in a class action, but certification does not necessarily remain in place for the entire case. As litigation develops, new evidence, changes in the claims, or problems with proving damages on a classwide basis may lead a court to reconsider whether the case should continue as a class action.

In New Jersey, a court may modify or decertify a previously certified class when the requirements for class treatment are no longer satisfied.

Why Can a Court Reconsider Class Certification?

New Jersey Rule 4:32-1 establishes several requirements for class certification. Among other things, the proposed class must satisfy requirements involving numerosity, common questions, typicality, and adequate representation. For certain types of class actions, common issues must also predominate over individual questions, and class treatment must be superior to other available methods.

Certification is not necessarily permanent. New Jersey’s class-action rules allow a certification order to be altered or amended before final judgment. The New Jersey Supreme Court has also confirmed that courts may reassess whether continued class treatment remains appropriate as a case develops.

Why Might a Class Be Decertified?

A defendant may seek decertification when later developments show that the class no longer meets the legal requirements for collective treatment.

Possible reasons may include:

  • Individual factual questions becoming more important than common issues
  • Significant differences among class members’ claims
  • Problems showing that the named plaintiff’s claim is typical of the class
  • Conflicts between the class representative and other members
  • Evidence showing that damages require highly individualized determinations
  • Changes in the applicable law
  • New evidence that changes the basis on which certification was originally granted

The court may also reconsider certification on its own as the litigation progresses.

Can Only Part of a Class Be Decertified?

Yes. Decertification does not always mean that the entire class action ends.

A court may modify the class definition, create subclasses, limit the issues that will receive class treatment, or decertify only a particular portion of the case.

The New Jersey Supreme Court’s decision in Little v. Kia Motors America, Inc. provides an important example. After a jury trial, the court determined that individual class members needed to prove their actual repair expenses separately. The Supreme Court upheld partial decertification on the damages issue because individual questions had become more significant than common ones.

What Happens to Class Members After Decertification?

The effect depends on the court’s order. In some cases, certain common issues may continue on a classwide basis while individual claims are handled separately. In other situations, former class members may need to pursue individual claims.

Decertification also does not necessarily mean that the original claims lacked merit. It may simply mean that the claims are no longer suitable for resolution together as one class.

Federal class actions filed in New Jersey operate under a similar principle. Federal Rule of Civil Procedure 23(c)(1)(C) allows an order granting or denying certification to be altered or amended before final judgment. Federal courts have therefore recognized that new evidence or developments during litigation can justify reconsidering whether class treatment remains appropriate.

Because certification can be revisited throughout a case, both plaintiffs and defendants must continue evaluating whether the claims satisfy the requirements for class treatment. A New Jersey class action attorney can analyze certification issues, respond to a motion for decertification, and determine how a change in class status may affect the rights of individual class members.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

X

×